The Infinity Sports Club

Matthew Looney 2 months ago

Wanted to quickly thank the Infinity Sports Club for hosting my daughter Helen’s birthday party. Clean facility, friendly staff and after using the court a HUGE party room that allowed my daughter and her friends to enjoy pizza and have a dance party. Highly recommended for birthday parties and team bonding events.

Christine Arcidiacono 2 months ago

I don’t leave five star reviews unless I truly believe a business has earned them, and this place absolutely has. I’ve been here countless times, whether it’s to play myself or support family members whose kids play here, and every visit has been a great experience. The facility is always clean, organized, and well run. I also couldn’t help but notice the sudden wave of one star reviews, and honestly, they don’t reflect the experience I’ve had. Reviews should be based on your actual experience, not used to hurt a business because you didn’t get your way. I felt the need to point that out because I’ve seen too many great local businesses take a hit over grown adults throwing tantrums after being held accountable for their actions and most importantly not respecting business owners rules… Every sports facility has rules and closing times. When the lights go off, that’s about as obvious as it gets that it’s time to leave. I respect that this place enforces the rules consistently because that’s what keeps it safe, enjoyable, and fair for everyone. I’ve watched so many kids, families, and teams enjoy this facility, and that’s why I felt the need to leave this review. Don’t let a wave

Azi Alam Edited 2 months ago

Our group had been renting courts at Infinity Sports Club for pickup basketball and always looked forward to playing there. Unfortunately, our experience on July 10, 2026 completely changed our view. We reserved and prepaid for our court well in advance. The booking was confirmed, and based on our communications, we understood that any upcoming price increase would not affect our already scheduled reservation. During our reserved court time, the lights were repeatedly turned off, interrupting our game. When a disagreement arose about pricing, we immediately offered to pay the difference so everyone could continue playing. Instead of accepting our offer and resolving the issue professionally, the owner, Anthony Menicola, began using profanity, and we were asked to leave before our reserved time had ended, which we did. Afterward, when we tried to discuss the situation and request a refund for the unused court time, the conversation became even more unprofessional. The owner accused our group of damaging a light switch without providing full evidence and later responded with more profanity over text. Disagreements can happen, and mistakes are sometimes made. What matters is how a

nifaz razzak 2 months ago

Terrible experience renting with owner. Extremely rude won’t book again.

Jersey Joe 10 months ago

Place is absolutely beautiful! Brand new floors were put in and they look amazing. They have some sort of extra special padding in them because all of us who played said it felt like we were not putting too much pressure on our joints. They have 3 courts and can be rented out per hour to accommodate all of your league and practice needs! After our basketball game they were setting up for volleyball on the other court. Definitely a state of art facility that will seem to house a ton of sports. This is affiliated with their flagship infinity club gym in Mahwah.